Mice and humans: replicated by independent labs. Cells and worms or flies: nothing yet.
C, W, M, H: cells, worms or flies, mice, humans. Dark: independent labs found the same change there. Light: one lab or one study. Outline: nothing yet.
Labs are independent when their papers share no last author and no institution.
Against: findings that point the other way from most findings on the same outcome.
Company ties: findings with an author at a company, or from a paper whose competing-interests statement declares ties to one.
135 independent labs in 34 countries
28 findings against
Funders: National Institute on Aging and others
22 of 237 findings with company ties
Human trial3
Humans511
Animals13
In silico1
What did studies of surgery find?
94
Studies of surgery measured 94 outcomes; the most studied are mortality (23 studies), cognitive function (12) and physical function (8).
Mortality
↓downin humans18↔no changein humans5HR 0.34–1.6
23 studies
Surgery is linked with lower mortality in humans (proximal humeral fracture, compared to non-operative treatment) (HR 0.88, 95% CI 0.84-0.91).
“Surgical treatment was associated with reduced overall mortality (HR 0.88; 95% CI 0.84-0.91).”
Humansproximal humeral fracture, compared to non-operative treatment
Journal of orthopaedic science : official journal of the Japanese Orthopaedic Association·
Surgery is linked with lower mortality in humans (aged hip fracture patients with comorbidities) (12.18% vs 24.69% at 1 year).
“Surgical group mortality rates at these time points (3.40%, 5.10%, 6.23%, 9.35%, 12.18%) were significantly lower than the non-surgical group (8.23%, 11.73%, 14.47%, 19.68%, 24.69%).”
Humansaged hip fracture patients with comorbidities1 yearn = 1,410
Surgery is linked with lower mortality in humans across all frailty strata (43%-77% reduction).
“Significant mortality reductions (43%-77%; P < .05) were observed in the operative cohort compared with the nonoperative cohort across all frailty strata.”
Surgery is linked with worse cognitive function in humans (elective non-cardiac surgery) (mean MoCA 20.9±3.2 to 18.0±2.6).
“The mean preoperative MoCA score was 20.9±3.2, which decreased significantly to 18.0±2.6 at 24 hours (p<0.001) and improved to 22.7±2.7 by postoperative day 30 (p<0.001).”
Surgery is linked with worse cognitive function in humans (elective surgery) (Preoperative: 25.94 ± 2.884; 3rd day: 24.18 ± 3.9; 7th day: 24.84 ± 3.62; 30th day: 25.23 ± 3.561; p < 0.0001; Partial Eta Squared (ηp2) = 0.98).
“The trend in incidence showed a gradual decrease in the mean Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) score from the 3rd postoperative day to the 30th day”
“Perioperative neurocognitive disorders (PNDs) are a spectrum of cognitive impairments that can occur after anaesthesia and surgery, most often in older adults.”
Surgery is linked with better physical function in humans (intracranial meningioma) (McNemar's chi-squared = 9.6, df = 1, p-value = 0.001946).
“The 1-year postoperative functional status of octogenarian meningioma patients who underwent surgery was significantly improved compared to pre-op mRS”
Journal of orthopaedic science : official journal of the Japanese Orthopaedic Association·
Surgery is linked with lower physical function in humans after colorectal cancer surgery.
“patients who were equal or older than 75-year-old and patients who received open surgeries tended to lose their muscle volume or physical performance after their surgeries.”
Surgery is linked with better physical function in humans (hip fracture) (63% vs 7%).
“Post injury mobility was significantly better in those who received operative treatment with 63% of surgical cases regaining ambulatory status versus 7% of conservatively managed patients.”
“Surgery is the preferred option for managing symptomatic endometriosis after the menopause, as it should reduce pain, ensure an accurate diagnosis, and decrease risk of malignancy.”
Surgery is linked with lower length of stay in humans (fragility hip fracture).
“The prompt surgical intervention (within 48 hours of admission) and the pre-injury mobility level influence the length of in-hospital stay of these patients (p<0.001).”
Surgery decreases skeletal muscle mass in humans (postoperatively (T1 to T3)) (-10.1%, 95% CI: -12.6, -7.7).
“Mid-thigh SMM increased from T1 to T2 (4.9%; 95% CI: 3.2, 6.5, p < 0.001); however, it decreased significantly from T1 to T3 (−10.1%; 95% CI: −12.6, −7.7, p < 0.001).”
Human trialpostoperatively (T1 to T3)≤1 month after surgeryn = 38
Surgery improves visual learning in humans after controlling for preoperative trend.
“Postoperative trajectories showed improvement compared to preoperative ones in the psychomotor function (p = 0.008), attention (p = 0.002) and visual learning (p = 0.007).”
Human trialafter controlling for preoperative trendn = 84
Surgery is associated with mortality in humans (hip fracture surgery) (morbidity 85.3%, mortality 5.0%).
“Postoperative morbidity and 30-day mortality were highest in those undergoing hip fracture surgery (morbidity 85.3% [413/484], mortality 5.0% [24/484])”
Surgery is linked with a lower risk of mortality in humans (older adult TBI patients with traumatic intracranial lesions) (OR 0.313, 95% CI 0.114-0.853, p = 0.023).
“older adult TBI patients who underwent early surgery had a statistically significant reduction in the risk of 30-day mortality (OR 0.313, 95% CI 0.114-0.853, p = 0.023)”
Humansolder adult TBI patients with traumatic intracranial lesions
Surgery is linked with a higher risk of in-hospital mortality in humans (colorectal EGS conditions) (+12% in multimorbid, +4% in nonmultimorbid).
“operative management was associated with a higher risk of in-hospital mortality among colorectal patients (multimorbid: + 12%, P < 0.001; nonmultimorbid: +4%, P = 0.003)”
Surgery is linked with a higher risk of delirium in humans (hospitalized with fractures).
“Risk factors were male gender, age ≥80 years, dementia, heart disease, osteoporosis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, high-energy traumas, pneumonia, urinary tract infection, and surgery.”
“The threshold concept explains the interaction of predisposing factors such as age, dementia, multimorbidity, malnutrition, substance use, and triggering factors such as surgery, infections, pain, and immobilization.”
Surgery is linked with a lower risk of frailty in humans within 12 months of index diagnosis (RR 0.98, 95% CI 0.98–0.99).
“Surgery within 12 months of index diagnosis demonstrated a significantly lower risk of metabolic burden (1-year RR [95% confidence interval (CI)]: 0.98 [0.98 to 0.98]; 3-year: 0.98 [0.98 to 0.98]) and frailty (1-year: 0.98 [0.98 to 0.99]”
Surgery raises the risk of postoperative delirium in humans.
“Multiple predisposing and precipitating factors contribute to its occurrence, including preoperative mental status, general physical condition, diabetes mellitus, electrolyte imbalances, type and duration of surgery, intraoperative blood loss, anesthesia management, and medication use.”
Surgery is associated with DNA methylation in humans (major surgery).
“Longitudinal perioperative studies further demonstrate acute and persistent methylation shifts following major surgery, notably within immune-inflammatory gene networks.”
Surgery is associated with cognitive impairment in humans (elective non-cardiac surgery) (37.0% (95% CI: 30.0%, 45.0%)).
“In elective non-cardiac surgeries, the pooled prevalence of unrecognized cognitive impairment was 37.0% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 30.0%, 45.0%) among 27,845 patients”
A model combining blood fats and clinical measures scored 0.817 at distinguishing postoperative cognitive decline, versus 0.734 for clinical measures alone.A model combining blood fats and clinical measures scored 0.817 at distinguishing postoperative cognitive decline, versus 0.734 for clinical measures alone.
At 12 months, 42.3% of matched patients aged 75 or older reached a meaningful neurological improvement threshold, versus 46.2% of younger patients.At 12 months, 42.3% of matched patients aged 75 or older reached a meaningful neurological improvement threshold, versus 46.2% of younger patients.
A 12-protein pattern was linked to delirium, which affected 26 of 88 older adults undergoing elective surgery.A 12-protein pattern was linked to delirium, which affected 26 of 88 older adults undergoing elective surgery.