Humans

Physical performance predicts fracture risk in older adults

In older men, a five-variable physical model beat FRAX without bone scans, raising 10-year fracture discrimination by an area under the curve of 0.052.

Figure 1 from Calcified Tissue International
Open the figure at full size
Figure 1Carvalho et al.

Calcified Tissue International

In community-dwelling older men and women, researchers evaluated whether an imaging-free model based on physical performance could predict 10-year fracture risk. The M5 model uses age, body-mass index, grip strength, gait speed, and chair-stand rate. The team analyzed data from 5,994 men in the Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study and 9,704 women in the Study of Osteoporotic Fractures with adjudicated incident major osteoporotic fractures. In men, M5 discriminated 10-year fracture risk better than FRAX without bone mineral density, yielding an AUC increase of 0.052, and performed similarly to FRAX with bone mineral density. In women, M5 did not differ significantly from a FRAX-surrogate comparator. Across both cohorts, adding bone mineral density measurements to the models yielded the highest discrimination.

Why it matters

Measures of physical performance track functional musculoskeletal decline and can gauge fracture vulnerability in older adults when bone densitometry is inaccessible.

Caveats

The findings require external validation because M5 was developed within these study cohorts, does not replace measured bone mineral density, and relied on a surrogate comparator rather than licensed FRAX scores in women.

The paper

Objective Physical Performance Predicts 10-Year Fracture Risk Without Densitometry in Older Men and Women: Development and Head-to-Head Comparison with FRAX in MrOS and SOF

University of Algarve · Centro de Ciências do Mar do Algarve

Calcified Tissue International · 1 Oct 2026

doi.org/10.1007/s00223-026-01618-3PubMed 42816672