Medicine

Diverse diet protects kidneys while carb restriction raises risk

Genetically predicted unrestricted eating reduced renal failure risk (odds ratio 0.1269), while avoiding sugar and wheat increased susceptibility.

Paper by Tao Liang, Feng Zhang, Fan Yang · The People's Hospital of LinXia · Linquan County People’s Hospital
Figure 1. Study flow diagram illustrating the causal impacts of dietary diversity and extreme dietary restriction patterns on RF.
Open the figure at full size
Figure 1. Study flow diagram illustrating the causal impacts of dietary diversity and extreme dietary restriction patterns on RF.Study flow diagram illustrating the causal impacts of dietary diversity and extreme dietary restriction patterns on RF.Liang et al.

Our read

Populations
Studied:
Mendelian randomization in people
In the record:
The 66th paper on dietary diversity with results in people; 102 on record in all.

Editor of record: Boris Djordjevic · AgingResearch.News

Follow @agingbrief

In a human genetic study, researchers analyzed summary-level genome-wide association study data to assess whether dietary patterns causally influence nonspecific renal failure. The authors first used univariable Mendelian randomization to examine an unrestricted "Eat all" pattern covering eggs, dairy, wheat, and sugar. They then used multivariable Mendelian randomization to isolate the effects of specific dietary exclusions while adjusting for overlapping habits.

Genetically predicted unrestricted eating exerted a significant protective effect against renal failure (odds ratio 0.1269, 95% confidence interval: 0.038–0.424). Conversely, specific carbohydrate exclusions emerged as independent hazards. Both "never eat sugar" (estimate 0.624, P = .026) and "never eat wheat" (estimate 2.292, P = .038) were independently associated with higher susceptibility to renal failure. Exclusions of eggs and dairy showed no significant independent effects.

Why it matters

Kidney function often deteriorates with age, and these results suggest that eliminating major carbohydrate sources may disrupt renal metabolic homeostasis. The findings urge caution regarding untargeted elimination diets promoted for metabolic health.

Caveats

The investigation relied on genetically predicted dietary habits from summary-level association data rather than randomized feeding trials. In addition, the genetic instruments reflected broad self-reported avoidance categories rather than precise nutritional intakes.

From the paper

Result

… the primary IVW analysis demonstrated that genetically predicted dietary diversity provides a robust and highly significant protective effect against RF (OR = 0.127, 95% CI: 0.038–0.424, P =.001).

Results, 3.2. Univariable MR: renoprotective effects of dietary diversity

Limitation

Firstly, our study focuses exclusively on populations of European ancestry, warranting caution when generalizing the findings.

4.1. Limitations

Quoted word for word from the full text on PubMed Central.

Comments

Be the first to comment.