The Lancet Neurology

Exercise plus a supplement raises fitness in Friedreich's ataxia

Peak oxygen uptake rose by 0.21 liters per minute with combination therapy compared with control, but was not statistically different from exercise alone.

Paper by Kimberly Y. Lin, Anna Bucha, Kara McSweeney, 23 more authorsShana Erin McCormack · Children's Hospital of Philadelphia
Randomized trial in 66 children and adults with Friedreich's ataxia, against the control groupInterventions

12 weeks, placebo-controlled, registered NCT04192136

Limit: Only 16 participants in the nicotinamide riboside and exercise group

Stake: An author takes fees from Elysium Health, which develops nicotinamide riboside. An author holds patents licensed to Altimmune. Authors also declare ties to 1 more company.

Edited by Boris Djordjevic · AgingResearch.News

Follow

In a randomized trial, researchers studied 66 people aged 10 to 40 with Friedreich's ataxia, including 37 males and 29 females, split equally between children and adults. For 12 weeks, participants received daily weight-based doses of 300 to 900 milligrams of nicotinamide riboside, an individualized home exercise program, both, or an inactive control.

Peak oxygen uptake during exercise rose by 0.21 liters per minute in the combination group compared with control. The combination did not differ statistically from exercise alone. Single treatments did not differ statistically from control, with ranges of likely values including no difference. Adverse events were all mild or moderate, mainly digestive issues, falls, respiratory infections, and rashes. Moderate events occurred in seven control participants, six taking the supplement alone, three in the exercise group, and four in the combination group. All participants completed the trial.

Why it matters

Friedreich's ataxia involves progressive neurodegeneration and impaired cardiopulmonary fitness, features shared with physical decline in older age. The trial bears on whether combining cellular metabolic supplements with physical training can help sustain functional capacity when organ systems degenerate.

Caveats

The trial was conducted at a single center over 12 weeks with 66 participants, and combination therapy did not show a statistically significant benefit over exercise alone. The results may not apply to people older than 40, those with heart ejection fractions below 45 percent, or individuals who already meet physical activity guidelines.

From the paper

Participants

Seventy-four individuals were enrolled, of whom 66 met eligibility criteria and were randomized.

Results

Who took part

Children and adults (10-40 years of age) with genetically confirmed Friedreich’s ataxia were recruited from clinical practices, website postings, and through a natural history study.

Methods, Participants

Duration

Total trial duration for each participant was 12 weeks and included a baseline visit (week 0), a 12-week intervention, and a follow-up visit (week 12).

Methods, Procedures

Result

The nicotinamide riboside only group experienced a decrease in body fat, whether expressed as visceral fat (−0·08 kg; 95% CI: −0·15, −0·005) or fat mass index Z-score (−0·18; 95% CI: −0·33, −0·02) versus control.

Results

Harms

There were no serious adverse events.

Results

Limitation

First, since Friedreich’s ataxia is a rare disorder, our sample was not sufficiently large to permit well-powered subgroup analyses.

Discussion

Peak VO2

Differences between active treatment and control were (95% CI, adjusted p-value): nicotinamide riboside only, 0·10 (−0·05, 0·26, p=0.188); exercise only, 0·16 (0·00, 0·31, p=0.103); combination, 0·21 (0·05, 0·36, p=0.0299).

Results

Maximal workload

With respect to other pre-specified CPET outcomes, maximal workload was increased by combination therapy relative to control, and O₂ pulse was increased similarly by both combination therapy and exercise only (, p.124), both relative to control.

Results

Physical activity

With respect to non-CPET outcomes, the Physical Activity and Disability Survey-Revised (PADS-R) exercise/leisure activity sub-score increased in response to combination therapy versus control (0·80, 95% CI: 0·13, 1·46).

Results

Quoted word for word from the full text on PubMed Central.