Aging Cell

More RNA from jumping DNA was not linked to shorter life in flies

Experiments in three fruit fly species challenged the idea that jumping DNA concentrated on the Y chromosome helps explain males’ shorter lives.

Paper by Miriam Merenciano, Sonia Janillon, Camille Mermet-Bouvier, +9 more authorsCristina P Vieira · UMR5558 Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1 Villeurbanne Rhône-Alpes France
Graphical abstract from Aging Cell
Open the figure at full size
Graphical abstract. Merenciano et al., CC BY

Our read

Mechanisms
Studied:
Experiments in male and female Drosophila flies
What changed:
Higher RNA levels from jumping DNA were not consistently linked to shorter male lifespan across fly strains
The catch:
Different sampling ages for older males and females could distort RNA comparisons
Why it’s aging research:
Lifespan, survival or healthspan.

Editor of record: Boris Djordjevic · AgingResearch.News

Follow @agingbrief

Fruit flies from three species—Drosophila melanogaster, D. simulans and D. suzukii—underwent laboratory experiments. Researchers compared lifespan in 277 strains, using 50 males and 50 virgin females per strain. They measured ribonucleic acid (RNA), molecules copied from DNA, in six inbred strains.

Transposable elements, or “jumping DNA,” are sequences that can move within a genome. Their RNA output rose with age in D. melanogaster and D. suzukii, but not D. simulans, without an overall sex difference. Older males nevertheless had more individual jumping-DNA copies with increased output than older females. Higher output was not linked to shorter lifespan. Swapping Y chromosomes between D. melanogaster strains progressively shortened male lifespan in a strain-specific way, alongside increased jumping-DNA output and changes in gene activity.

Why it matters

The authors suggest that jumping DNA may matter less for sex differences in lifespan in species with little of it. They suggest Y chromosome effects depend more on variation in its tightly packed DNA and interactions between genes than on jumping-DNA abundance.

Caveats

The RNA measurements did not establish whether jumping DNA moved to new locations. They came from two inbred strains per species, with older sampling ages varying across strains.

Where the evidence stands

Chromatin and 3D genome organization

Cells, worms or flies, mice and humans: a single group.
  • 58 independent labs in 23 countries
  • 2 findings against
  • Funders: National Institutes of Health and others
  • 12 of 87 findings with company ties

Transposable element activity

Cells, worms or flies and mice: replicated by independent labs. Humans: a single group.
  • 41 independent labs in 18 countries
  • Funders: National Institute on Aging and others
  • 12 of 62 findings with company ties

From the paper

Result

In addition, lifespan differed significantly between the two strains in both males and females (Log-Rank test, p < 0.001 for each sex; hazard ratio = 0.24, 95% CI [0.18, 1.35] for males; hazard ratio = 0.58, 95% CI [0.46, 0.74] for females) (Figure 5C).

Results, 2.7 Y Chromosome Replacement Is Associated to Increased SGL by Reducing Male Lifespan in D. melanogaster

Quoted word for word from the full text on onlinelibrary.wiley.com.

Comments

Be the first to comment.