BMJ

Coaching modestly increased steps in adults with limited mobility

At six months, daily steps were 931 higher with coaching than with no intervention, and 571 higher than with text messaging.

Figure 1 from BMJ
Open the figure at full size
Figure 1. Pearce et al.
Studied:
Randomized trial in 436 community dwelling adults with mobility limitations, six months (Blinded, registered ACTRN12618001983291)
What changed:
Adults receiving coaching averaged 931 more daily steps than the waitlist group at six months
The catch:
Knowing the trial’s aims could change participants’ walking while wearing activity monitors
In the record:
One of 4 papers on physical activity coaching on record: 2 with results in people.

Editor of record: Boris Djordjevic · AgingResearch.News

Follow @agingbrief

512 community-dwelling adults with self-reported mobility limitations participated in a randomized controlled trial with three groups. Their average age was 69, and 76% were women. They reported difficulty or inability to walk 800 meters but could leave home without another person's physical help.

Participants received six-month multicomponent programs featuring physiotherapist phone coaching every two weeks or regular one-way text messages, or no intervention. At six months, device-measured daily steps were 931 higher with coaching than with no intervention and 571 higher than with texting. Texting's advantage over no intervention was uncertain: the range of likely values included no difference. Adverse events were reported in 11 of 172 coaching participants (6%), seven of 171 texting participants (4%) and 13 of 169 controls (8%). None were serious.

Why it matters

With participants averaging 69 years, the trial addressed how to support physical activity in later life when walking is difficult.

Caveats

The trial included only people able to leave home without another person's physical help. It does not show whether coaching helps people who need that assistance.

Where the evidence stands

Text messaging

Humans: a single group. Cells, worms or flies and mice: nothing yet.
  • 9 independent labs in 6 countries
  • 1 finding against
  • Funders: National Cancer Institute and others
  • 2 of 20 findings with company ties

Physical activity coaching

Humans: a single group. Cells, worms or flies and mice: nothing yet.
  • 2 independent labs in 2 countries
  • Funders: Comunidad de Madrid and 1 more

From the paper

Primary outcome

A difference was not detected in mean daily steps between the texting and waitlist groups at six months (between group difference 359 steps, 95% CI -91 to 810 steps; P=0.12).

Results, Primary outcome

Limitation

Secondly, the waitlist control group received the texting intervention at six months, limiting comparisons with a no intervention control at 12 months.

Strengths and limitations of this study

Quoted word for word from the full text on bmj.com.

Comments

Be the first to comment.