NPJ Dementia

Dementia screening test needed changes for Shawi adults

Among 434 Shawi adults aged 50 and older, a five-item version fit the test data better than the original six-item version.

Paper by Alicia Boluarte Carbajal, Arantxa Sánchez-Boluarte, Marleny Nolasco, Mónica María Díaz · Universidad César Vallejo · University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Fig. 1. Visualization of RUDAS-PE response ratios.
Open the figure at full size
Fig. 1. Visualization of RUDAS-PE response ratios.Visualization of RUDAS-PE response ratios.Boluarte Carbajal et al.

Our read

Biomarkers
Studied:
Cross-sectional study of 434 Shawi adults aged 50 and older, against original 6-item structure
What changed:
A five-item version fit the test data better than the original six-item structure
The catch:
Statistical model fit was evaluated; diagnostic accuracy for dementia was not measured

Editor of record: Boris Djordjevic · AgingResearch.News

Follow @agingbrief

In an observational study, 434 Shawi Indigenous Amazonian adults aged 50 and older completed a culturally adapted cognitive screening test in rural Peru. Researchers used community feedback, interviews and pilot testing to revise the Peruvian version of the Rowland Universal Dementia Assessment Scale, which assesses thinking and memory.

The original six-item structure fit poorly with a statistical model in which all items measure general thinking ability. A five-item version, excluding a drawing task, fit better. On the drawing task, 82% received the minimum score of zero. Only 14.9% of participants knew how to use a pencil. The authors concluded that culturally valid adaptations, particularly of drawing tasks, were essential to avoid diagnostic bias in Indigenous populations.

Why it matters

The work addresses a barrier to early dementia detection in older Indigenous adults: screening tools that have rarely been validated for their communities.

Caveats

Better statistical fit does not establish how accurately the test identifies dementia. Average measurement consistency was modest, and the findings concern Shawi adults in rural Peru.

Comments

Be the first to comment.