International Psychogeriatrics · Nov 16, 2026

Critical methodological vulnerabilities, data discrepancies, and mechanistic paradoxes in evaluating repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with Tai Chi for mild cognitive impairment

By Ye Y, Hu J

This correspondence provides a critical methodological and statistical re-appraisal of the recent clinical trial by Bai et al. (2026) [1], which investigated the combination of Yang-style Tai Chi and neuronavigated 1-Hz repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) for older adults with mild cognitive impairment and co-occurring sleep disorders. While evaluating non-pharmacological multimodal interventions in psychogeriatric populations represents a vital scientific pursuit, our in-depth evaluation reveals substantial vulnerabilities that undermine the trial's confirmatory conclusions. First, improper post-randomization exclusions of baseline-ineligible individuals resulted in an attrition rate exceeding 32%, fundamentally violating the intention-to-treat principle. Second, Table 1 displays critical computational discrepancies, including missing participant counts, impossible non-integer frequencies, and mathematically implausible test statistics (x² and P-values). Third, reliance on raw change-score analyses rather than baseline-adjusted ANCOVA leaves the behavioral findings vulnerable to Lord's paradox and regression to the mean. Fourth, the neuroimaging findings present a mechanistic paradox-wherein functional connectivity gains in the sham arm significantly exceeded those in the active group-compounded by non-independent seed selection ("double dipping"). Finally, the twice-daily high-density regimen incurs feasibility challenges, while evening inhibitory rTMS introduces chronobiological inconsistencies lacking objective sleep verification. We urge the authors to clarify these data discrepancies and recommend that the proposed synergistic effects be interpreted with caution.

doi.org/10.1016/j.inpsyc.2026.100321PubMed 43039826Interventions

AgingResearch.News