Current Developments in Nutrition · Nov 2026
Plant food diversity is more favorable to diet quality than animal food diversity – evidence from a microsimulation study
By Bolo A, Chabert S, Wang J et al.
Background Dietary diversity is a longstanding principle in dietary guidelines, yet it is often formulated and perceived generically, despite the fact that its effects may vary by food group. Objective Against the backdrop of the ongoing shift toward more plant-based diets in high-income countries, this study compares the modeled effects of increased dietary diversity within plant-based versus animal-based food groups on diet quality. Methods Using individual-level diet microsimulations based on observed adult diets from a representative French dietary survey (INCA3, n=1,125), we modeled a maximal increase in diversity within selected food groups of plant or animal origin, while keeping total consumption levels constant. Diet quality was evaluated using probabilistic scores for nutrient adequacy, nutrient security (risk of overt deficiency), and moderation (avoidance of excessive intakes of sugar, sodium, and saturated fat). Additionally, chronic disease risk was modeled using a comparative risk assessment framework applied at the individual level. Data were analyzed using energy-adjusted repeated-measures linear mixed models. Results Effects are expressed in SD units of the observed diets. Under the simulated scenarios, increasing diversity within animal or plant food groups improved nutrient adequacy (+0.63 SD [95% CI: 0.60, 0.66] and +0.52 SD [0.49, 0.55], respectively) and security (+0.42 SD [0.38, 0.46] and +0.32 SD [0.29, 0.35], respectively), with slightly larger improvements for animal diversity. Moderation worsened only when diversity was increased within animal food groups (−0.33 SD [-0.37, -0.28]). The score reflecting lower chronic disease risk improved about three times more with plant (+0.94 SD [0.88, 0.99]) than with animal diversity (+0.32 SD [0.27, 0.38]). Conclusions In this microsimulation study, maximizing diversity within plant food groups resulted in more favorable overall diet quality, particularly regarding modeled chronic disease risk, whereas maximizing diversity within animal food groups had mixed effects, including adverse impacts on moderation. Teaser textModeled increased diversity within plant (vs animal) products has a more favorable effect on diet quality, in particular regarding limiting excessive nutrient intakes and modeled chronic disease risk.