PsyArXiv · Nov 18, 2026

Inconclusive evidence for prospective effects between digital media usage and cognitive health: A reassessment of Che et al. (2026)

By Sorjonen K, Melin B, Melin M

Using cross-lagged panel models, Che et al. (2026) reported bidirectional longitudinal associations between digital media use and cognitive health in older adults. However, statistically significant cross-lagged paths cannot by themselves establish the presence of genuine prospective influences because similar findings may arise from alternative data-generating processes. In the present study, we generated simulated data that reproduced the sample size and correlational structure reported by Che et al. and examined whether their conclusions were robust across several reasonable analytical specifications. The pattern of results differed substantially depending on the model employed. Certain specifications suggested positive prospective associations, whereas others produced negative or non-significant effects. When estimates from all analytical approaches were combined using meta-analytic methods, neither overall effect differed significantly from zero. These findings indicate that current evidence is insufficient to support strong claims regarding reciprocal prospective effects between digital media use and cognitive health. Following recommendations from the multiverse-analysis literature, conclusions should be based on the consistency of findings across defensible analytical choices rather than on a single preferred model.

doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/7j432Open accessPopulations

AgingResearch.News