Research Square · Jul 31, 2026

Processing versus nutrients: What drives the health risks of ultra-processed foods?

By Sun Q, Wang Y, Fan Z et al.

Consistent observational associations between ultra-processed food (UPF) consumption and multiple chronic diseases have led to UPFs being treated as a broadly homogeneous dietary risk category. However, adverse health effects attributed to UPF-rich diets may reflect both nutritional and physical properties that frequently accompany ultra-processing, rather than processing status alone. Moving beyond this constrained view of food quality, we developed a large language model-assisted Nutritional Integrity Index (NII)—a continuous food-level score integrating nutrient information with ingredient- and processing-related semantics extracted from food descriptions. Across 7,083 foods consumed in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, NII showed strong concordance with established nutrient profiling systems while revealing substantial nutritional heterogeneity within NOVA-defined UPFs. Nutrient-only proxy models explained 81.3% of the variation in NII, and SHapley Additive exPlanations (SHAP) analyses identified physiologically coherent non-linear nutrient interactions. Higher UPF intake was associated with increased mortality risk, whereas higher NII was associated with lower all-cause mortality across all UPF intake levels. In joint analyses (high/low UPF intake × high/low NII score), mortality tracked NII rather than UPF intake, and within‑NII shifts in UPF consumption had no significant impact on all-cause, cancer, or heart disease mortality. These findings suggest that the health relevance of UPFs varies according to nutritional integrity and that processing classification alone does not fully characterize dietary risk. Indices based on nutritional quality that integrate processing status are more likely to reflect meaningful dietary exposures.

doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-10513803/v1Open accessBiomarkers

AgingResearch.News