Frontiers in Public Health · Nov 10, 2026
Mendelian randomization evidence linking shift work tolerance factors to breast cancer risk: a narrative review
By Dat Thien Tran, Juergen Degenfellner, Susanne Strohmaier et al.
Emerging evidence suggests that tolerance to shift work is a complex trait that is influenced by circadian (chronotype), sleep-related, psychological (neuroticism, extraversion), and behavioral/lifestyle (coffee/alcohol consumption, vitamin D) factors. Despite growing recognition of the importance of shift work tolerance, it remains unclear whether it modifies the previously reported association between night shift work and breast cancer risk. This narrative review aimed to summarize the literature on genetic instruments used to assess the causal effects of factors influencing shift work tolerance on breast cancer risk and survival, and to identify factors that warrant further study in the context of the association between night shift work and breast cancer. PubMed and Google Scholar were searched up to June 2, 2026, and 33 studies were included. Genetically predicted morning chronotype was associated with lower breast cancer risk in six studies examining it, although most used the same genetic instruments and outcome data and thus do not represent independent replication. Longer sleep duration was associated with higher risk in four of six studies, and obstructive sleep apnea and neuroticism were each associated with higher risk in a single study. No clear causal associations with breast cancer risk were observed for other genetically instrumented predictors of shift work tolerance, including insomnia (four studies), caffeine consumption (four studies), alcohol intake (six studies, with weak genetic instruments), vitamin D levels (11 studies) and extraversion (one study). However, one study reported a potential survival benefit of vitamin D in estrogen receptor-negative breast cancer, which requires further validation. Furthermore, we identified no published studies examining interactions between genetically instrumented correlates of shift work tolerance and night work in relation to breast cancer risk. This review underscores that the genetic relationships between shift work tolerance factors and breast cancer risk remain insufficiently explored and merit further investigation, particularly among night shift workers.