Preprint · Jan 17, 2024
Does age affect metacognition? A cross-domain investigation using a hierarchical Bayesian framework
By Meunier-Duperray L, Mazancieux A, Souchay C et al.
According to previous research, the accuracy of metacognitive judgments in aging depends on the cognitive domain involved in the task, the experimental design, and the metacognitive index used. Older adults are frequently less accurate than younger adults in judging their episodic memory, while no difference is typically observed for semantic metamemory. In addition, age-related changes in metaperception appear to be highly task-dependent. Other metacognitive domains (such as metacognition of executive functioning) have been seldom explored. This study aimed to integrate methodological and theoretical advances in the study of metacognition to answer the question of whether metacognition is impaired in healthy aging. Data were collected in a large sample (n = 443) of participants aged 18 to 79. Participants provided retrospective confidence judgments in four domains: episodic memory, semantic memory, executive functioning, and visual perception. Our measure of accuracy, metacognitive efficiency, was estimated using a hierarchical Bayesian implementation of the meta-d’ model. Results showed that metacognitive efficiency decreased with age in the episodic task. A trend towards an age effect was noted in the executive task. There was no effect of age on metacognitive efficiency in the semantic and perception tasks. Furthermore, results suggested that metacognition of older adults may rely more on domain-specific processes than that of younger adults. The influences of frontal functioning and cognitive changes on metacognition are discussed.