Mayo Clinic Proceedings · Nov 11, 2026

Diet Quality Versus Physical Activity and Cardiorespiratory Fitness for Longevity: A Review of Comparative Evidence

By Gaesser GA, Sallis RE

Poor diet quality and insufficient physical activity (PA) are major modifiable risk factors for chronic disease and a shortened lifespan. Public health priorities have historically emphasized dietary modification more than increasing PA, and this disproportionate emphasis persists in current initiatives. We searched PubMed for applicable articles to evaluate the relative associations of diet quality, PA, and cardiorespiratory fitness (CRF) with all-cause mortality (ACM). Evidence from meta-analyses and prospective cohort studies indicates that: (1) a sedentary lifestyle is associated with substantially greater excess mortality risk than poor diet quality; (2) lower ACM risk associated with high PA or CRF exceeds that associated with high adherence to healthy dietary patterns or greater consumption of plant-based foods; (3) increases in PA or CRF are associated with lower ACM risk than improvements in diet quality; (4) in studies examining joint associations, PA or CRF is more strongly associated with ACM than diet quality, with several studies showing that high PA or CRF largely eliminates excess mortality risk associated with lower diet quality; and (5) exercise prevents or attenuates adverse cardiometabolic and vascular effects of short-term unhealthy dietary challenges, whereas dietary interventions are largely ineffective in offsetting the physiological consequences of physical inactivity. These findings do not diminish the importance of a healthy diet but indicate that the disproportionate focus on diet relative to PA in current public health priorities is not supported by the comparative evidence. Collectively, the results support greater public health emphasis on increasing PA and improving CRF when the primary goals are longevity and reduction of chronic disease mortality.

doi.org/10.1016/j.mayocp.2026.10.010Open accessPubMed 43014478Populations

AgingResearch.News