JTO Clinical and Research Reports · Nov 2026

Impact of Removing the 15-Year Since Quitting Smoking Criterion and Replacing Pack-Years with Smoking Duration on Lung Cancer Screening Eligibility

By Potter AL, Guo Q, Zhu A et al.

Introduction We evaluated how relaxing or removing the 15-years-since-quitting (YSQ) smoking requirement and replacing the 20-pack-year requirement with a 20-year duration requirement in the 2021 U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) lung cancer screening recommendation would affect screening eligibility. Methods Participants who formerly smoked in the Southern Community Cohort Study (SCCS) and Multiethnic Cohort Study (MECS) were identified. We analyzed sensitivity and specificity of the 2021 USPSTF recommendation, the American Cancer Society (ACS) guideline, and a hypothetical guideline removing the 15-YSQ requirement and replacing the 20-pack-year requirement with a 20-year duration requirement (“20-year-duration/no-quit-year guideline”). Hypothetical guidelines using different smoking cessation intervals were evaluated. Results Of 21,053 SCCS and 74,894 MECS participants, 568 and 2,499 were diagnosed with lung cancer, respectively. Sensitivity of the USPSTF recommendation was 49.3% in the SCCS and 18.8% in the MECS. As the quit-year threshold was progressively relaxed, sensitivity increased and specificity decreased, with generally greater increases in sensitivity among White individuals. Sensitivity of the ACS guideline was 67.4% in the SCCS and 40.0% in the MECS, but racial and ethnic differences persisted. The 20-year-duration/no-quit-year guideline increased sensitivity to 85.2% in the SCCS and 53.0% in the MECS, and reduced racial and ethnic differences. Specificity ranged from 80.7-97.1% for the USPSTF recommendation, 64.1-86.8% for the ACS guideline, and 41.4-78.9% for the 20-year-duration/no-quit-year guideline. Conclusion Compared with the USPSTF recommendation, the ACS and 20-year-duration/no-quit-year guidelines had higher sensitivity and lower specificity. Replacing the 20-pack-year requirement with a 20-year duration requirement reduced racial and ethnic differences in sensitivity.

doi.org/10.1016/j.jtocrr.2026.101117Open accessBiomarkers

AgingResearch.News